THE Sculpting Challenge - 004 - Voting

[Knut]

THE Sculpting Challenge - 004 - Voting

The fourth sculpting challenge final entries are in (http://forums.3dtotal.com/showthread.php?t=59331) and it's time to decide a winner. This job rests in the hands of you, the participants and spectators! We're sticking to the same voting system as earlier. Find your three favorite entries and rank them from first to third giving them points according to this formula:

1st: 3 points
2nd: 2 points
3rd: 1 point

-Only the rank and names are required, and we would prefer if the thread is kept clean of chatter and such, but feel free to give a reason why you chose the ones you did.
-In order for your vote to be valid, your post count must be 50 or above to prevent a "fixed election". Only exception is if you have contributed an entry yourself.
-It goes without saying that all voters MUST look through each of the entries before posting their score, and only entries from the final submissions thread are valid.
-Don't vote for yourself. :lame:

We will add up all the points and announce the winner on Tuesday July 1st (In a week) at 10:00 AM GMT, or if we see it fit before that (no votes for 24 hours etc).

Best of luck to everyone!

[ClassicGamer-3DT]

1st: Crab People (Krang is perfect, exactly what we were looking for in this challenge, incredibly well detailed and just brilliantly sculpted.)
2nd: kazmamurat (An amazing Mr Incredible, bursting with character and style, superb sculpt!)
3rd: MonteCristo-3DT (D&D's Venger the ultimate baddie, and the ultimate badass sculpted counterpart, flawless construction again and beautiful detailing!)

It's also worth mentioning Emeth003's Uncle Fester which blew me away aswell.

This wasn't easy at all whatsoever!

Kind Regards
CG.

[chrisskinner]

1st - Crab People
2nd - Kazmamurat
3rd - Emeth003

Great work everbody! Looking forward to getting stuck into the next challenge.

[kazmamurat]

this time it 's harder than before to vote only 3 works, there are many of great works, unfortunately I must select only three of them,

my choice;

1. Mantis (amazing detailing and clean sculpt for limited time)
2. Emeth003 (as always, great work)
3. Katonc (awesome idea and realistic sculpting)

[MonteCristo]

Yup. This is V tricky.

1. kazmamurat - Been my favourite for a long time. It's quality.
2. Pap97 - A cool sculpt as well.
3. Fireantz - I love this sculpt.

[funkdelic]

1 - Kazmamurat
2 - Guhhh
3 - Intervain

[shakey3d]

1. Emeth003
2. WildWire
3. Intervain

[Mantis]

1-Kazmarut- My favorites for a long time too :)
2-Pap97- Really great sculpt that perfectly fit to the challenge.
3-Rwijaya- Really love this one too.

These three are my favorites not only because they are great but also because they put a real effort to respect the challenge theme.

[bgen]

1. pap87 - to me u nailed the topic down. and the sculpt is great as well.
2. kazmamurat - same here spot on topic. to bad he isn't as chubby like in the pixar movie :p.
3. MonteCristo - ace.

[ianchaos]

1. kazmamurat
2. Emeth003
3. freesupra

[M3N7H0L5]

This gave me a hard time..:cry::wall:

1::Emeth003-you always nail em
2::Fireantz-the way you manipulate the mesh..just superb
3::<del>Pap97</del>Pap87-the closest looking sculpt to the cartoon by far

[guhhh]

harddd choice!!

1. Kazmamurat
2. MonteCristo
3. rwijaya

[clee101]

It was very tough to choose..

1. pap87-excellent transition from cartoon to real-life. Great quality sculpting.

2. Crab People- very interesting and fun to look at. Nice details.

3. Emeth003- high quality sculpt, great transition, nice expression.

[freesupra]

1 - Mantis
2 - Pap87
3- Kazmamurat

[VersionThirst]

This was hard:

1. Crab People - so much detail in the little time allowed, very nice
2. biano3d - really, really love the proportions and how clean the sculpt is
3. MonteCristo-3DT - awesome sculpt, awesome character

[inveni0]

For voting, I was trying to look at the topic. There were some really nice quality sculpts, but not all stayed on topic. So, here's my picks:

1) kazmamurat - Mr. Incredible looks great. This is by far my favorite. You've foregone any stylization, yet made it an obvious real-life counterpart of the big I himself.

2) guhhh - Gargamel...geez. What a great idea! You've definitely captured the creepiness. He's a bit too stylized, but the addition of his cat is nice. Good work.

3) Emeth003 - Uncle Fester looks good...plain and simple. We've already seen his real life counter part via a couple of feature films, so I can't give you a better vote. Technically, however, the modeling is good...so third place for you!

[redonix76]

1. clee101
2. kazmamurat
3. fireantz

[Neoncypher]

1. Kazmamurat - Brilliant stuff
2. Pap87 - Loved this when I saw it, really looks like a real life Asterix
3. FreeSupra - Really like this, a dark Krusty

I think these three really captured what this competition was about, and taking part has really inspired me to improve my Zbrush skills. Well done everyone!

[dalton_muniz]

1 -Pap87
2- Rwijaya
3- kazmamurat

[thee]

1.krang by Crab people
2.Fester by Emeth003
3.judy jedson by bryzol

[Puckducker]

1st: kazmamurat - Impeccable work. Taking a character that's not widely visualized and making him instantly recognizable in "human" form.
2nd: Katonc - represents perfectly the theme of this week's challenge. Awesome sculpt. Everyone knows Raph was the best though....
3rd: Emeth003 - this sculpt is oozing with style. The pose/expression is dead on perfect.

[Sathe]

Crab People- Well deserved man, well deserved
Pap87- The best cartoon to real life conversion
Coridium- Big fan of this character

[Crab People]

1. rwijaya
2. Pap87
3. Emeth003

[AutopsySoldier]

1. Crab People
2. ale3dfx
3. kazmamurat

[ncollings]

According to the rules etc.. and because they are greatly done. here is my top 3 :).

1: kazmamurat
2: pap87
3: Emeth003

congratz guys , well done !

[mafida]

Haard choice...
1 kazmamurat-l liked groo the wanderer more but...
2 dalton_muniz -great expression
3 Intervain -for style

[Coridium]

Have really enjoyed watching the entrys to this comp, heres my votes...

1st - kazmamurat - just love it, brilliant interpretation of the source material.
2nd - WildWire - Love the clean and sharp lines to this model.
3rd - Emeth003 - great sculpt and perfect expression.

But welldone all, it was really difficult to pick out 3.

[ryvick]

1st - Pap87 - you have captured everything of this character and turned it into real life. Amazing.
2nd - kazmamurat - if i could tie you in with 1st place i would. Perfect replica.
3rd - rwijaya - wow if you had a bit more detailing you would have won this competition in my opinion. you got his attitude in your sculpt as well. great job.

this was fun, i wouldnt mind having this competition come around again.

[ylpunk]

1st KatonC
2nd biano3d
3rd Fireantz

[Sandpiper]

1 - Kazmamurat
2 - Katonc
3 - Emeth003

HM - guhhh

Great execution all around. :)

Jesse

[Osky]

1. Kazmamurat
2. MonteCristo
3. Crab People

[oliver1]

1-Ordibble Plop


2-Mantis



3-Emeth003




Alex Oliver

[spoiLars]

kazmamurat - incredible
wildwire - popeye
freesupra - crusty


1st : freesupra - Crusty the Clown. This sculpt was to me not only technically impressive, but it really captured what I hoped to see come out of this challenge. Lots of personality in this one

2nd : wildwire - popeye - awesome and clean design and sculpt. Love its sharp yet simplistic nature.

3rd : kazmamurat - mr. Incredible - Impeccable sculpt and conversion of the character.

[Intervain]

1. Rwijaya
2. Pap87
2. kazmamurat


best of luck all :)

[DJdude]

1:Coridium: Night crawler;incredibly realistic sculpt. the matcap's great for the character.
2:kazmamurat: Mr. Incredible; amazing detail.
3:M3N7H0L5:Majin Buu; I've never seen the character before but something about it just captures me.

[Ordibble Plop]

1: Pap87 (Asterix) - he has an indomitable air to him, true to the character

2: rwijaya (Donald Duck) - great expression and risky interpretation

3: JHarford (Danger Mouse) - DM was my favourite cartoon so I'm biased, but I really like the interpretation - he seems quite chirpy and energetic

[Korda]

For a moment there I thought I wouldnt be able to vote, being a newbie and all.
anyway here are my votes.

1. Kazmamurat - Mr. Incredible
I thought you kind of cheated doing a 3D character but your translation from stylised to realistic was truly...wait for it..... Incredible


2. Pap87 - Asterix
I think you followed the guidlines better than anyone and the sculpt is really great but you do realise you have to make Obelix now

3. Fellipe Lopes - panthero
I really like this one and i'm not entirely sure why. I think you really captured the personality and the sculpting is also very good.


I also really liked these ones but thought their entries didnt follow the guidelines close enough:
Intervain – hades
Wildwire – popeye
Emeth003 – fester

[pap87]

1 - kazmamurat (mr. incredible)
2 - rwijaya (donald duck)
3 - crab people (krang)

Such hard decisions to make. Pat on the back to all!

[rwijaya]

1. kazmamurat (bob Mr.incredible)
2. pap87 (asterix)
3. intervain (hades)

Very though decision! cos all of them are really great.
good luck with everyone.

[Deepam]

It was really hard to choose top 3, but after a long I hv decided -

1st - Emeth003
Fester (nice resemblance plus character expression and feeling according to 3d version)

2nd - Intervain
Hades (nice resemblance plus balanced proportions and character features)

3rd - pap87
Asterix (well developed real version of a stylized character)

[skywalkerluis]

1-Fireantz
2-Crab People
3-Mantis

www.youtube.com/skywalkerluis

[fireantz]

1. bryzol - She look sexy & i luv it much.
2. Emeth003 - Nice sculpting & design for it~!
3. dalton_muniz - Luv the expression.

[Salimor]

1st kazmamurat (Mr. Incredible)
2nd pap87 (Asterix)
3rd Katonc (Donatello)

[biano3d]

1-Kazmamurat
2-PAP87
3-Emeth003

congratulations to all!!!

[M_Cederstrom]

Great work every one.

1. Intervain
2. kazmamurat
3. Emeth003

[Aleks]

1 - WildWire
2 - pap87
3 - Emeth003

[WildWire]

Great work everyone.

1. kazmamurat (Mr. Incredible)

2. Ordibble Plop (Mickey)

3. Emeth003 (Fester-Addams Family)

I also really like:
Mantis-Skeletor, Intervain-Hades, ncollings-Woverine, rap-Batman
MonteCristo3DT-Venger, rwijaya-Donald, freesupra-Krusty,
Coridium-Nightcrawler and pap87-Asterix

[bryzol]

1 - MonteCristo - what can we say?... Champion...
2 - Kazmamurat - realy nice and clin sculpting, I realy like face mimic.
3 - Fireantz - It is so different from others. I love it!

It was a very difficult decision to choose only three sculpts, I have to mention about: Manthis, Wildwire, Emeth, Ordibble Plop, Pap87. If I could I whould place fev scoulpts on each possition. Good luck to All of you!

[capitan_popo]

1st Mantis that skeletor is killer the heart in the hand just made it the winner for me
2nd Wild wire Great portrayal of popeye awesome sculpt
3rd Kazmamurat love that u can recognize him without a second look

[Wartooth]

1st: dalton_muniz
2nd: pap87
3rd: cojoMan

great sculpts everyone

[rap]

1st-Emeth003
2nd-intervain
3rd-MonteCristo

so hard to choose only 3! had so many favorites...
really gave me a headache:hurt: